Update

Refreshing CSE’s Bylaws: Report from the Bylaws Review Task Force

Bylaws serve as the constitution of a nonprofit organization, defining its internal rules, structure, and operations. Although they may seem like inside baseball to many association members, bylaws are critical to organizational functioning and a go-to resource for elected leaders.

Guidance varies, but the US Chamber of Commerce, for example, recommends reviewing bylaws regularly, such as every 3–5 years, to ensure they remain aligned with an organization’s needs and practices.1 CSE’s bylaws were last updated in 2011, which, for those of you counting, was 15 years ago.

It has not been for lack of trying. Throughout my time on the CSE Board of Directors and beyond, updating the bylaws was a known necessity. Every so often, a situation rising to the Board level would call attention to a gap, ambiguity, or anachronism that needed to be addressed. That said, a bylaws update is neither easy nor quick. Bylaws are critical infrastructure, have legal implications, and, under the 2011 bylaws, proposed changes must be ratified by the membership before they take effect. It is a daunting task and not one to be undertaken in a hurry. Had we but world enough and time!

Although the need had been on the Board’s radar for some time, other situations, tasks, and challenges continued to demand priority and resources. Transitions in association management and executive leadership, the pandemic, and myriad changes in our industry contributed to the timeline. In 2025, Past President Emilie Gunn made it a priority to address a related series of longstanding administrative needs.

Having experienced firsthand during my term as CSE President (2021–2022) the frequency with which complications arise necessitating bylaws consultation, and the compounding challenges of those bylaws having been written for a different time, I was thrilled when Emilie asked me to chair a task force to refresh the bylaws for CSE. I was joined by a fantastic team of current and former CSE leaders, all familiar in different ways with the particulars and peculiarities of CSE’s dusty old bylaws and eager to bust out their proverbial red pens: Amanda Ferguson, Carissa Gilman, Christina Nelson, and Peter Olson.

As someone very wise once told me, the bylaws should serve the needs of the organization, not the other way around. With this guiding principle in mind, throughout the latter half of 2025 and into 2026, our task force conducted a comprehensive review and revision of CSE’s 2011 bylaws to ensure that our governance framework reflects current organizational needs, modern nonprofit standards, and the evolving needs and expectations of our membership. As part of our review, the task force consulted association industry guidance regarding bylaws form and function, including resources from ASAE and Candid, among others, and evaluated bylaws from a variety of nonprofit scientific and publishing professional associations. 

Although the proposed revisions are extensive, many modernize the bylaws’ structure, clarify governance procedures, or move operational details to policies that can be maintained by the Board and standing committees. The purpose of bylaws is not to address every facet of association management; when it comes to bylaws, less is often more. For example, bylaws may require the organization to maintain a conflict of interest policy and a code of conduct without incorporating the full policies. Similarly, removing detailed information about dues and member benefits does not itself eliminate those practices; it recognizes that this level of operational detail does not belong in the bylaws.

Key changes in the proposed bylaws include:

  1. Minor changes to wording throughout that do not change meaning but add clarity to existing bylaws.
  2. Membership will be assumed to continue unless CSE is notified that a member wishes to resign their membership.
  3. The President will appoint committee chairs but not the individual members of each committee.
  4. Updated membership categories to reflect current practice.
  5. Flexibility for expansion of the CSE Board of Directors by adding additional Directors (up to 6) or other non-voting positions deemed necessary by the Board.
  6. Revised guidance to address known gaps in election and Board vacancy procedures:
    1. Filling positions that become vacant before the elected official takes office or if an elected official cannot take office.
    2. Handling a tie in election outcomes.
  7. Reasons a Board member may be removed.
  8. Reflection of modern communication capabilities.
  9. Greater detail regarding Board of Directors meetings, including scheduling and what shall constitute a quorum.
  10. Inclusion of Science Editor leadership on the Board of Directors in a non-voting capacity.
  11. Provisions for more timely updates of the bylaws, including allowing the Board to approve and implement bylaws changes immediately, provided the changes are ratified via member vote within 1 year.

For the complete proposed bylaws, a summary of the major changes, and voting instructions, see CSE’s 2026 bylaws revision page.

In addition to revising the bylaws, our task force recommended that the Board establish a regular review cycle, every 3–5 years, with the CSE Secretary overseeing the process so that a member of the Board is accountable for keeping the bylaws current. That recommendation is being taken up as Board policy rather than written into the bylaws themselves; it will be posted on the CSE website once finalized, and it falls within the Secretary’s existing responsibility for maintaining CSE’s core organizational documents.

All CSE members in good standing are eligible to vote, and the vote will remain open for three weeks; the opening and closing dates and voting instructions are available on the bylaws revision page linked above. I encourage you to review the proposed bylaws and cast your vote. Together, we can help ensure that CSE’s bylaws continue to serve the organization and support its mission.

Reference

  1. OFlaherty D. Ensuring Success: Why Regular Bylaw Reviews Are Essential. U.S. Chamber of Commerce. 2025 Sep 24 [accessed 2026 Oct 20]. https://www.uschamber.com/chambers-of-commerce/ensuring-success-why-regular-bylaw-reviews-are-essential

Discussion

Leave a Comment